CREATE YOUR OWN MIX - Salt Water Taffy - Choose From 80+ Flavors - Taffy

WE ARE THE ONLY COMPANY ON THE INTERNET that will pick your taffy (Flavor or Color Theme) exactly as you choose. Our listing is perfect for you.

There's something for every taffy lover in this listing of 80+ flavors of individually wrapped pieces of salt water taffy. Whether you're having a pinata birthday party, a wedding, or wanting to freeze dry this delicious treat, you'll enjoy the intense flavors of Taffy Town saltwater taffy. Great for weddings, baby showers, the office or breakroom, or "just-because".

WHAT SETS US APART FROM ANY OTHER TAFFY SELLER, EVEN TAFFY TOWN?

We visit Taffy Town twice a week....Usually Monday's and Wednesday's, to *fill our taffy orders.

BECAUSE WE'RE THERE SO OFTEN, WE CAN FULFILL YOUR ORDER TO YOUR FLAVOR/COLOR SPECIFICATIONS. Your taffy will be fresh as we have the convenience of picking it directly from Taffy Town upon ordering. (Taffy Town is literally in our back yard).

PLEASE LEAVE US YOUR FLAVOR SELECTIONS (Flavors Listed Below) in the "Personalization: Create Your Own Mix" section and we'll pick out your flavors according to the listing quanity you ordered. (Note: Some flavors may be out of season or out of stock so give us alternate flavors just in case if it's a big deal to you.)

*Please allow for up to 5 days for us to fulfill your order.

Buy yours today and enjoy fast shipping!

We thank you for your business in advance.

Taffy is from Taffy Town and packaged/shipped by The Candy Crave, a division of Logic Dealz, LLC!

* 8 oz PERSONAL - Approximately 30 Pieces

* 1 Lb SHARE (16 oz.)- Approximately 60 Pieces

* 3 Lb FAMILY (48 oz.)- Approximately 175 pieces 

* 5 lb PARTY TIME (60 oz.)- Approximately 300 Pieces

Choose ANY FLAVOR COMBINATION OF YOUR CHOICE from the following list and let us know what you want in the "Add Your Personalization" box:

Apple Pie

Banana Cream Pie

Banana Split

Banana

Black Licorice

Blackberry Crumble

Blueberry

Boysenberry Syrup *(New 2026 Flavor)

Bubble Gum

Butter

Buttered Popcorn

Butterscotch

Candy Apple

Candy Corn

Caramel Apple

Caramel Swirl

Cherry Cola

Cherry Limeade

Cherry

Chili Mango

Chocolate Caramel Mocha

Chocolate Caramel Sea Salt *(New 2026 Flavor)

Chocolate Chip

Chocolate

Cinnamon Roll

Cinnamon

Coconut

Cookie Butter

Cookies & Cream

Cotton Candy

Cran-Raspberry

Dirty Soda

Eggnog

French Toast *(New 2026 Flavor)

Frosted Cupcake

Fruity Cereal

German Chocolate Cake

Glazed Donut

Golden Pear

Gourmet Caramel

Grape

Green Apple

Honey

Hot Chocolate

Huckleberry

Key Lime

Kiwi Strawberry

Lemon Cream

Mango

Maple Bacon

Maple

Neapolitan

Orange Cream

Orange

Passion Fruit

Peanut Butter and Jelly

Peaches ‘N Cream

Peanut Butter

Peppermint

Pickle

Pina Colada

Pineapple

Pineapple Upside Down Cake *(New 2026 Flavor)

POG (Passionfruit+Orange+Guava)

Pumpkin Pie

Raspberry Lemonade

Raspberry Blue

Red Licorice

Red Velvet Cake

Rocket Pop

Root Beer Float

S’Mores

Shaved Ice

Strawberry Banana

Strawberry Cheesecake

Strawberry

Sugar Cookie

Tangerine

Tropical Punch

Vanilla

Watermelon

INGREDIENTS: CORN SYRUP, SUGAR, COCONUT OIL, EGG WHITES, SEA SALT, EVAPORATED MILK, CITRIC ACID, MALIC ACID, COCOA, SUNFLOWER LECITHIN, TITANIUM DIOXIDE, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR, ARTIFICIAL COLORS

Want SUGAR-FREE Taffy? Choose from the following flavors:

*SF Banana

*SF Chocolate

*SF Cinnamon

*SF Raspberry

*SF Strawberry

*SF Vanilla

Ingredients: MALTITOL SYRUP, COCONUT OIL, SEA SALT, EGG WHITES, MALIC ACID, EVAPORATED MILK, NATURAL FLAVOR, ARTIFICIAL COLOR (INCLUDING FD&C BLUE1) *CONSUMPTION MAY CAUSE STOMACH DISCOMFORT AND/OR LAXATIVE EFFECT. INDIVIDUAL TOLERANCE WILL VARY.